It’s long been said that dogs can sense fear, but it seems they can also sniff out dishonesty. That’s right—your furry friend might be more perceptive than you think. A recent study out of Kyoto University in Japan suggests that dogs are surprisingly good at determining whether a person is trustworthy. This research, led by Akiko Takaoka, reveals that dogs can quickly decide if they should believe what you’re telling them.
The Experiment That Fooled Dogs
To explore how dogs evaluate human behavior, researchers designed an experiment that involved a bit of trickery. Scientists already knew that dogs tend to follow a human’s gestures, especially when someone points towards an object. So, they put this knowledge to the test. In the first phase of the study, researchers pointed to a container that had hidden food inside. Naturally, the dog went right for it.
Next, the researchers pointed to an empty container. Even though the dog eagerly approached, there was no food to be found. Now came the most telling moment of the study: on the third attempt, the researchers again pointed to a container filled with food. But this time, the dogs didn’t move. After being tricked once, they no longer trusted the person’s guidance.
In total, 34 dogs participated in the study, and every single one of them refused to follow the final gesture. They had learned that the human wasn’t reliable. Whether it’s a matter of spotting a lie or simply having trust issues, the dogs showed they were quick to catch on.
Trust Once Broken, is Hard to Earn Back
This fascinating study highlights how dogs can gauge the reliability of humans, and once that trust is broken, they’re hesitant to give it back. “Dogs have more sophisticated social intelligence than we thought,” said Takaoka, who was surprised at how quickly the dogs seemed to “devalue the reliability of a human.” Once lied to, the dogs were not willing to take another risk.
This kind of social intelligence is thought to have developed through the long history of dogs living alongside humans. Their ability to read human cues has been refined over thousands of years of domestication.
Why Predictability Matters
John Bradshaw, a researcher from the University of Bristol, provided further insights, although he wasn’t directly involved in the study. According to Bradshaw, the findings point to the fact that dogs crave predictability. When a person’s actions don’t match their words—or gestures, in this case—dogs can become anxious or stressed.
For dogs, consistency in their human companions’ behavior seems to be key. Inconsistent signals can make them feel uneasy and unsure of what to expect. This may explain why a dog can quickly lose trust in someone who deceives them, even if just once.
What About Wolves?
Researchers are planning to take their study one step further by testing the same experiment on wolves. Since wolves are the closest living relatives to dogs, the scientists hope to uncover how domestication has shaped the social intelligence of dogs over time. However, the goal isn’t to provoke a bite from the wolves, but rather to see if the wild animals have the same keen sense of trust as their domesticated counterparts.
Lessons for Dog Owners
So, what does this all mean for dog owners? The bottom line is simple: if you want your dog to trust you, be consistent and honest. Dogs appear to value a person’s reliability more than we ever realized. Once you lie to them or send mixed signals, it could take a long time to earn back their trust.
Takaoka’s study gives us an incredible glimpse into the social intelligence of dogs. It turns out, they’re watching us closely, learning who’s reliable and who’s not—and they make up their minds fast. Whether it’s their long history with humans or a natural instinct, one thing is clear: dogs are much smarter than we often give them credit for.
In other words, your dog knows more about your trustworthiness than you might realize.
GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings