MSNBC is shaking things up, and one of its most controversial voices is out. The network has officially canceled “The ReidOut,” Joy Reid’s 7 p.m. ET show, a decision that has sparked celebration among conservatives and outrage from liberals.
The prime-time shake-up is part of a broader shift at MSNBC, which will replace Reid’s program with a panel-style show featuring Symone Sanders-Townsend, a former spokesperson for Vice President Kamala Harris, along with Alicia Menendez and former RNC Chair-turned-MSNBC-host Michael Steele.
Conservatives Say ‘Good Riddance’
For conservatives, the news was long overdue. Joy Reid, known for her heated takes on Trump supporters and Republicans, had been a frequent target of criticism. Former FCC chairman Ajit Pai sarcastically remarked, “An unfortunate development for Joy Reid’s viewer, considering the host’s insightful analysis on political topics.” He shared a clip of Reid praising Kamala Harris’ “flawlessly run campaign”—despite her failed presidential bid.
Actor Michael Rapaport chimed in with a sharp response, posting the hashtag #joyless.
Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene, R-Ga., shared her thoughts on X, formerly Twitter, saying, “The ad execs and the board finally figured out that racism, lies, and Trump derangement syndrome will put them out of business.”
Throwback to when Joy Reid suggested that Trump surviving the shooting and going immediately to the RNC was be exactly the same as Joe Biden beating Covid and going to the DNC. Unsurprising her show is cancelled. pic.twitter.com/gL0zENSuSf
— T.J. Moe (@TJMoe28) February 23, 2025
Liberals Outraged Over the Decision
While conservatives cheered, MSNBC’s liberal audience wasn’t happy. Some took to social media to express frustration, accusing the network of unfairly targeting Reid.
Keith Olbermann, a former MSNBC host, blamed “Morning Joe” co-host Joe Scarborough, arguing the network didn’t have a Joy Reid problem, but a “Joe Scarborough problem.” He wrote, “Until he is fired, MSNBC will not recover. Shuffling tepid shows in and out does nothing.”
MSNBC has canceled Joy Reid’s show.
Here she was in 2022, saying that most Americans don’t really care about inflation and don’t even know what the word means. They won’t vote based on it:pic.twitter.com/WYJd9cjt25
— Geiger Capital (@Geiger_Capital) February 23, 2025
Olbermann also criticized the new panel format, saying, “Panel shows with multiple meh hosts don’t work in primetime in cable news. They didn’t work in 2003… even those executives understood the need for strong solo anchors.”
Reports are that MSNBC’s evening show “The ReidOut” is being canceled. An unfortunate development for Joy Reid’s viewer, considering the host’s insightful analysis on political topics. pic.twitter.com/Ol8K8z0b1H
— Ajit Pai (@AjitPai) February 23, 2025
Liberal writer Wajahat Ali pointed to race as a factor, saying, “She’s a blunt Black woman, so of course her show is canceled. Not lost on any of us.”
Dean Obeidallah, a radio show host and frequent MSNBC contributor, also criticized the decision, pointing to the “Morning Joe” hosts and their controversial past interactions with Trump.
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!
Good, and not cause I wanna see anyone lose a job good because you had an opportunity & pissed it away with short sighted racially weaponized 1/4 truth garbage
And they did it on a SUNDAY morning,
double HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA#joyless #joyreid pic.twitter.com/WGQJThOWUz— MichaelRapaport (@MichaelRapaport) February 23, 2025
Danielle Moodie, host of The Daily Beast’s “The New Abnormal” podcast, slammed MSNBC for its history of removing Black female-led shows first. “Every time MSNBC has a ‘shake-up’ the Black woman solo-led show is ALWAYS the first to go,” she wrote.
Good morning!!
MSNBC just canceled Joy Reid’s show.
The ad execs and the board finally figured out that racism, lies, and Trump derangement syndrome will put them out of business. pic.twitter.com/OUYXRuXBYp
— Marjorie Taylor Greene 🇺🇸 (@mtgreenee) February 23, 2025
Joy Reid was one of the most toxic people in the media; good riddance https://t.co/giFFcuTASw
— Charles Gasparino (@CGasparino) February 23, 2025
Mixed Reactions as Reid’s Legacy is Debated
Despite the controversy, some voices in media praised Reid’s contributions. NewsNation’s Kurt Bardella credited her with helping launch his career. “The 1st person at MSNBC to give me a regular place on a show was Joy Reid. I would not have a career in cable news without her. She has elevated so many diverse voices and paved a way for so many. Whatever she does next will be equally impactful.”

MSNBC has yet to make an official announcement detailing the reasoning behind the change, but one thing is certain—the decision has drawn strong reactions from both sides of the political spectrum. Whether the network’s new panel show will succeed where “The ReidOut” struggled remains to be seen.
GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings